Analysis of BLACKPINK Collaborating with Selena Gomez on 'Ice Cream'

In the world of music collaborations, not all pairings strike a chord with fans. The recent collaboration between BLACKPINK and Selena Gomez for the single 'Ice Cream', while generating a buzz initially, seems to have fallen flat with many listeners. This article delves into the opinions and insights surrounding the collaboration, analyzing the reception and aftermath.

Initial Reactions

For many fans, the initial reaction to the announcement of the collaboration was mixed. While personal admiration for Selena Gomez and the members of BLACKPINK exists, the collaboration itself received a lukewarm response. Some felt that the group had not been given adequate opportunities to showcase their talent. Consequently, the group's initial comebacks were limited, and their growth in the Western music industry might have come easier than to many other artists, potentially leading to a sense of complacency.

Reception of 'Ice Cream'

The song 'Ice Cream' gained a more affirmative reception upon deeper listening. Early criticisms suggested that the song felt too rushed and unprofessional, highlighting a disparity in the contribution from each artist.

Selena Gomez received a larger portion of the song, dominating the narrative with more lines and screen time. This approach to the collaboration did not sit well with fans who felt that Lisa and Jisoo were underrepresented. The other members of BLACKPINK were only present in the chorus, and Jisoo's part was notably brief, adding to the impression of an uneven distribution of the spotlight.

Producer’s Touch

Another significant criticism of the collaboration was the song's beat, described as 'wonky and strange'. Fans noticed that the song's rhythm felt clunky, and the way the artists sang to the beat was perceived as distorted and unnatural.

Aftermath and Fan Reactions

Though the initial enthusiasm for the collaboration was high among Selenators and Blink (BLACKPINK's fanbase), the actual experience was fraught with controversy and disappointment. The song's lackluster reception led to tensions between fans of the two artists, with the Selenators and Blink sometimes clashing over the collaboration. However, the collaboration ultimately served as a learning experience, fostering a deeper bond and understanding between the fanbases.

Despite the challenges, both Selena Gomez and BLACKPINK members expressed mutual respect and support, supporting one another's music. The collaboration, while not a commercial success, played a significant role in bringing the two fanbases closer together.

In conclusion, the collaboration between BLACKPINK and Selena Gomez for 'Ice Cream' offers a critical look into the dynamics of cross-genre music collaborations and highlights the importance of unity and support within fan communities.