Are Romans Proud of Being Italian and a Part of Italy? Unveiling Cultural and Historical Realities
"Oh, yes, they are everywhere you go in Roma, you will see SPQR being the symbol of the city."
As someone of Italian descent and an American, I have experienced both pride and anti-Italian ridicule. Despite certain political elements that have tarnished my perspective, I still find great love for Italy and wish to share my experience with you. If I had to live elsewhere, it would indeed be on the Amalfi coast. But there is more to the story than meets the eye. In the United States, when people discuss Italy, it often comes with a complex mix of pride and criticism. So, what do Americans really say when talking about Italy behind our backs?
The Ugly Truth: America's Perspective on Italy
"We are Americans and we are not only proud of it we are NUMBER ONE! We say we are proud because we kicked everyone’s butt in World War One AND World War Two! WE SAY we are Number One because if not for us you'd all be speaking... not Italian but German!"
"You Italians have a great glorious past but the last great Italian was Christopher Columbus because he had the smarts to leave Europe and go to America where he could be Number One!"
"You Italians should thank us because otherwise you’d still be licking the Fuhrer’s boots. And what have you invented in 500 years other than Pizza which we Americans improved on anyway."
These sharp words reveal the underlying arrogance and self-importance that often accompany discussions about Italy in the US. However, it is crucial to recognize that such views are only one perspective, and they should not define the rich and complex history of the Italian people.
The True Legacy of Rome
The reality is that Rome has left an indelible mark on Italian identity. According to genetic testing, many residents of Rome proudly claim a direct connection to the ancient Roman Empire. When people assert that modern Italians are not truly descended from Romans, they are missing the broader historical context.
The only Italians who truly benefit from this pride are, in fact, Romans. This sentiment is particularly evident among taxi drivers in the city, who often claim that their family lineage has remained in Rome since the days of the Empire. While it is true that Italy has faced numerous invasions, each of which has contributed to its rich cultural tapestry, it is equally important to recognize the enduring legacy of Rome.
The DNA of Italy: A Complicated Historical Mix
Italy, like other regions of Europe, is a mosaic of different influences and invasions. My wife, for instance, is from Naples, but her surname is Norman, indicating Norman influence. My own background is more Germanic, yet I share the same Italian heritage in physical appearance. This illustrates the complex historical and genetic composition of modern Italy.
Prospective statements like, "Our grand grand grand grandfathers were centurions," are often romanticized but not necessarily meaningful in today's context. While acknowledging the historical contributions of the Roman Empire, it is important to recognize that the lives of most modern Italians are not directly tied to the actions or identities of individuals from that era. Instead, the present-day connection is more abstract, reflecting the cultural and educational influence of Roman history on contemporary Italian society.
Conclusion: A Team Effort in Understanding
While it is essential to explore the complexities of Italy's past, it is equally important to foster a nuanced understanding of the present. All cultures evolve and change over time, and the Italian identity is no exception. Recognizing the contributions of ancient Rome while also acknowledging the layers of influence from various invasions and migrations can help us appreciate the multifaceted heritage of Italy. It is a shared story, and every part of it deserves respect and honoring.
So, whether you are an American or an Italian, let us strive to understand and celebrate the richness of each other's cultural and historical legacies. After all, the true essence of any nation lies not in the myths of the past but in the unity and diversity of its people in the present.