Can You Become a Composer Without a Degree?
The path to becoming a composer is often perceived as requiring a formal education and structured training, but this perception can be misleading. While a degree and formal training provide a solid foundation, it is possible for individuals to develop their skills and create compelling music without these traditional pathways. However, the journey can be challenging and unpredictable.
True Story: Faking Credentials in Medicine
A long time ago, a man who was working in medicine as a surgeon and in medical research was discovered to have faked his credentials in order to secure his job. He lacked formal education and training: before a medical procedure, he would read up on the topic in advance. For some years, he managed to function satisfactorily in the position, though he eventually lost his job when his fraud was uncovered.
One day, this same man approached a violin teacher I knew. He expressed his desire to learn the Beethoven violin concerto. When the teacher asked how long he had been studying the violin, the man replied, 'I've never played but I want to start learning.' After convincing him that he might need a series of lessons, the teacher agreed to take him on as a beginner student.
After several lessons, the teacher realized that the man had made little progress. When he finally quit, he could only play “Twinkle Twinkle Little Star.” This man quickly realized that he couldn't fake his way through the complex Beethoven violin concerto the way he had faked his way through his medical career.
The lesson here is that while anything is possible, it often doesn't happen without a solid understanding of the subject matter and the skills required to excel in it.
The Importance of Training and Experience
When it comes to composing music, training and experience are crucial. Just like the violinist, a composer needs to know the fundamentals of their craft to produce coherent and meaningful works. Training helps composers develop the technical skills necessary to execute their ideas and understand the nuances of music theory and composition. A lack of this foundational knowledge can result in either poor execution or an inability to progress further in the field.
Does anyone truly become a composer without training? In some cases, yes, but often these individuals are the exceptional few who possess a natural talent for music and are willing to put in extraordinary effort. Most composers benefit from formal education or structured training to guide their development.
Artistic Talent and Synthesis
Artistic talent varies widely among individuals. Some people may not be able to become mathematicians despite extensive efforts, but they might excel in arts due to their unique brain wiring. It is important for young individuals to explore various fields to discover their true talents and passions. Engaging in diverse experiences helps identify areas where one can shine.
There is a spectrum of skill levels within any profession, including music. While some individuals with minimal training have managed to make significant contributions, these are typically at the top of the professional spectrum. Most people fall somewhere along this continuum, improving with training and practice.
The Role of Marketing and Networking
Beyond the practical skills, becoming a well-known composer involves more than just creating music. Networking and marketing are vital components of a composer's career. Access to opportunities, performance venues, and reliable marketing channels can significantly influence a composer's success. Without these, a composer's work might go unnoticed.
Is it possible to become a composer with minimal training? In an ideal scenario where all factors align, it is possible. But this scenario is rare and usually applies only to exceptionally talented individuals. For the majority, the combination of training, experience, and networking contributes to achieving a successful career in composition.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while it is possible to become a composer without a degree or formal training, it is not a straightforward path for most people. Training provides the necessary skills and knowledge, and networking and marketing can help a composer gain recognition. However, for those with an innate talent and a willingness to work hard, the journey to becoming a composer can be rewarding and fulfilling.