Should I Get Sennheiser HD 598 or Audio Technica ATH-m5 as My First Monitor Headphone?

Totally up to you whether you want open-back or closed-back headphones. Both the Sennheiser HD 598 and Audio Technica ATH-m5 are excellent options, though I would lean towards the Sennheiser HD 598 for their accuracy and comfort. Open-back headphones like the Sennheiser HD 598 do not block outside sound, whereas closed-back headphones like the Audio Technica ATH-m5 offer noise isolation.

Which to Choose: Sennheiser HD 598

I would recommend the Sennheiser HD 598. They are more accurate and comfortable, with a less modern look than some of the newer options. The Audio Technica ATH-m5, on the other hand, do a great job of blocking outside sound, but the Sennheiser HD 598 are perhaps more versatile for monitoring purposes.

Sennheiser HD 598 Overview

The Sennheiser HD 598 does not boast an overly modern appearance, but it maintains a highly comfortable build with high-quality sound. Its sophisticated design is suitable for a retro enthusiast, and the 150 price tag is a fantastic deal for pure audio performance.

One downside of the HD 598 is their lack of portability due to the absence of a carrying case or foldability. They are, however, ideal for use at home due to their size and perfect acoustics. Their bass is quite good but might not satisfy those who require a powerful, punchy bass.

Pros of Sennheiser HD 598

Crisp equal sound distribution Comfortable fit and size Retro style

Cons of Sennheiser HD 598

Inadequate bass (may not satisfy all audiophiles)

Alternative Option: V-MODA Crossfade M-100

For those seeking an additional option, I recommend the V-MODA Crossfade M-100. This headphone delivers a 3D soundstage and smooth bass, enhancing a deep and immersive listening experience. Vocals are clear and balanced, providing a professional studio listening experience.

V-MODA M-100 Sound Quality

3D Soundstage for an immersive experience Smooth bass that balances treble Vibes made comfortable for studio listening

V-MODA M-100 Build Quality

The V-MODA Crossfade M-100 features 50mm Dual-Diaphragm Drivers that maintain equal sound distribution, ensuring a balanced treble and bass. These high-end drivers and materials exceed the performance of other headphones in the same price range. The noise isolation feature effectively cuts out ambient noise, ensuring a clear listening experience. The memory foam cushions conform to the listener's ears, adding to the comfort.

V-MODA M-100 Versatility

Custom shield kits for personalization Optional cables for enhanced functionality

V-MODA M-100 Awards and Recognition

The V-MODA Crossfade M-100 has won 17 editors’ choice awards and was crowned the best headphone in its class for two consecutive years by DJ Mag. This recognition speaks to its superior performance and attention to detail in design.

V-MODA M-100 Durability

SteelFlex Headband for flexibility and strength Interchangeable Metal Shields for protection Exoskeleton Form-Fitting Case for durability Durable cables and plugs for long-lasting performance

V-MODA M-100 Portability

The Cliq fold hinge allows these headphones to fold compactly for easy storage, and the V-STRAP system inside the case ensures neat and organized cables. The case also has space for other accessories like USB drives or earbuds, and a carbine clip safely attaches the headphones to the outside of a bag.

V-MODA M-100 Detachable Cables

The dual-input feature allows mixing two audio sources simultaneously. Additionally, a button control mic cable is included, and extended length cables compatible with various devices and professional equipment are also available.