Is Andrew Eldritch a Bass or Baritone?
The classification of Andrew Eldritch’s vocal range has been a point of discussion among music enthusiasts for years. While his Wikipedia article categorizes him as a bass-baritone, he is also included in a list of baritones in non-classical music. The discrepancy in his vocal classification raises interesting questions about his vocal range and performance.
My Perspective on Andrew Eldritch's Voice
From my personal experience and listening to his voice in an uploaded interview on YouTube, I have always considered Andrew Eldritch to be a bass singer, albeit one positioned on the higher end of the bass spectrum. His voice has a certain presence that aligns more with the characteristics of a well-trained bass singer rather than a deep baritone. However, the possibility of him being a low baritone with an extended lower range cannot be ruled out either. The distinction between a bass and a baritone can sometimes be subtle, with voice types often overlapping in their tessituras.
An Analysis of Voice Classification
Voice classification is a complex field that relies on a combination of several factors, including vocal range, tessitura, and vocal timbre. The bass-baritone and baritone classifications are based on specific criteria within this framework:
Bass-Baritone
The bass-baritone is a classification that includes singers with a wide range capable of singing both bass and baritone parts. These singers typically have a strong mid to high bass range and a solid baritone range. Famous bass-baritones include Joshua Bell and Bryan Harnen. The bass-baritone range often extends from the low F or E to the high F or G.
Baritone
A baritone is a male singing voice that sits between the bass and tenor voice types. Baritones are known for their rich, powerful sound and are capable of singing throughout the tenor and bass ranges. Notable baritones include Plácido Domingo and Yusuf Apooghai. They typically have a range from the A below middle C (A2) to the A above middle C (A4).
Andrew Eldritch's Voice Characteristics
Andrew Eldritch, born in Birmingham, England, is the frontman of the influential post-punk band Bauhaus. His voice is characterized by its distinctive tone and power, which has earned him recognition as a rock and alternative music icon. In interviews and performances, Eldritch’s vocal range often extends beyond the typical baritone range, hinting at a more versatile and flexible vocal mechanism.
Listening to Interviews and Performances
By listening to interviews and performances where Andrew Eldritch vocalizes, it becomes evident that he can sing in a lower range that aligns more with a bass-baritone. However, in other parts of his performances, his voice takes on a higher, more ringing quality, which can be characteristic of a baritone. The versatility of his voice is a testament to his vocal training and natural ability.
Conclusion
Based on my personal experience and the complexity of voice classification, it seems that Andrew Eldritch's classification as a bass-baritone is a logical fit. However, his vocal range can certainly be heard as extending into baritone territory, especially in certain parts of his performances or interviews. The definitive answer may lie in a thorough analysis of his voice, including vocal range charts and expert vocal assessments.
Related Keywords
- Andrew Eldritch - Bass singer - Baritone - Bass-baritone - Voice classification - Bauhaus band