Should I Buy the Vinyl Record Reissue or the Original Issue?

As a dedicated record collector but on a budget, you will undoubtedly encounter the question of whether to buy an original record or a reissue. This decision is pivotal in the collector's world, governed by a mix of sonic quality, historical value, and emotional attachment.

Sound Quality: Reissues vs. Original Issues

There are two primary reasons favoring original records in terms of sound quality. Firstly, mass production can lead to a loss of detail. During the production of a record, the master tape is used to create an initial lacquer disc, which is then used as a matrix for subsequent duplicates. This process, however, can result in a less detailed sound, affecting the overall listening experience.

Secondly, sounding mastering is often more accurate in initial pressings. Sound engineers may work closely with bands and producers to ensure that the final product is as close to the intended artistic outcome as possible. This can result in a richer and more authentic sound.

However, high-quality reissues can now provide a nearly identical listening experience. Proper digital remastering can enhance the sonic details, making them almost indistinguishable from the original recordings. Therefore, compromises must be balanced with the intended artistry of the work.

Non-Audio Benefits of Original Issues

Beyond just the sound quality, original records carry significant value and enjoyment through their packaging and artwork. These early pressings often come with thick vinyl, hard cardboard covers, vivid pictures, and unique layouts that may be altered in reissues. Here are some key factors:

Historic value: Owning the very first pressing can feel like holding a piece of history, with a 'back-in-the-day' atmosphere. Artwork and packaging: Original records were often sold with special enhancements like gatefold covers, colored inner sleeves, lyric booklets, and other memorabilia. Items like Jethro Tull’s “Thick As A Brick” and the Beatles’ “Let It Be” offer fascinating examples of original packaging that are rarely replicated in reissues. Psychological attachment: The packaging and artwork are integral parts of the listening experience. The feeling of holding a genuine first pressing can be deeply satisfying for collectors.

The Case for Reissues

While original issues undoubtedly have their appeal, reissues offer several advantages, including:

Cost-effectiveness: Original records can be prohibitively expensive. Reissues, especially high-quality ones, can be more accessible, making them a practical choice for collectors with limited budgets. Resale value: Original records retain their value better over time, but reissues can also remain valuable if they are highly regarded and in good condition. Playability: Original records, being rare and often stored for long periods, may wear out faster. Reissues ensure that you can enjoy your collection without compromising the value of your original records.

Deciding Factors and Advice

Here are some key considerations to help you decide:

Analyze your budget: Judge how much you can realistically spend. Original records can be extremely expensive, so reissues may be a more viable option. Verify authenticity: Ensure that the record you are considering is indeed an original pressing. This can be complex and time-consuming, as there are many variables to consider. Compare options: If an original issue fits your budget, embrace the history and artistry it represents. Otherwise, a decent reissue can still provide a fantastic listening experience.

Ultimately, the decision hinges on your passion and tolerance for compromise. If you can afford and find an original issue that meets your requirements, go for it. Otherwise, a high-quality reissue can still bring hours of joy and satisfaction.

Happy record collecting!