Producer Advice Confusion: Making Music for Yourself vs. Criticism
As an emerging musician, you're often faced with differing opinions and advice from producers on how to craft your music. It's a perplexing situation when a bunch of producers tell you to make more music for yourself, but then criticize your work when it deviates from what they consider 'industry standards.' This article explores the complexities of this common confusion and offers insights on how you can navigate the tricky waters of independent music production.
Understanding the Conflicting Guidance from Producers
First, it's important to recognize that producers often have different motives and expectations when they offer advice. Some producers genuinely want to help you develop a distinct style, while others might have their own production styles that they want to impart. The criticism that follows might stem from a different perspective or simply a lack of interest in your unique sound.
Why Producers Encourage You to Make Music for Yourself
Producers often suggest you make music for yourself because:
Authenticity: Encouraging you to stick to your own style and sound helps you stay true to your identity as an artist. This authenticity resonates with your fans and gives you a sense of fulfillment as a creator.
Personal Growth: Working on your own music challenges you to be innovative and grow as an artist. It can push you to explore new sounds and techniques that you might not have tried otherwise.
Brand Identity: A consistent and unique sound helps build a recognizable brand. This can make your music more memorable and easier for fans to identify.
Why Producers Criticize Your Music If You Didn't Ask for It
Unfortunately, not everyone in the music industry shares your passion for innovation and creativity. Some producers and critics might feel disenchanted with what they perceive as the industry's obsession with 'heavy drops.' Here are a few reasons why this criticism might arise:
Boredom: Constant exposure to the same production techniques can lead to boredom and frustration. Producers might be looking for something fresh and different.
Pressure to Innovate: With the rapid evolution of music production technology and trends, there's a constant pressure to come up with new and exciting sounds.
Commercial Expectations: In a highly competitive market, some producers and music industry professionals might feel pressure to produce content that aligns with commercial expectations rather than artistic creativity.
Thoughtful Steps to Navigate This Dilemma
Understanding the reasons behind both the advice and criticism can be helpful. Here are some steps you can take to navigate this complex landscape:
Reflect on Your Goals: Determine what you want to achieve with your music. Are you more focused on personal expression or commercial success? This clarity will guide your choices.
Seek Diverse Feedback: Don't rely solely on the opinion of one producer. Gather feedback from a variety of sources, including peers, fans, and your target audience.
Stay True to Your Voice: Embrace your unique style and continue to evolve it. This authenticity will set you apart and attract your true fans.
Learn, Expand, and Collaborate: Stay informed about new production techniques and collaborate with other musicians to bring fresh perspectives to your work.
Conclusion
The confusion surrounding advice from producers is understandable. By recognizing their intentions and taking thoughtful steps to navigate your own musical journey, you can find a balance between staying true to yourself and evolving your craft. Remember, the key is to maintain your authenticity and continuously push boundaries to create something truly unique.