The Art of Composition: Determining the Length of Modern Musical Works

As a classically trained musician, I have long pondered the question of how long a modern musical composition should be. My focus is on fully notated, composed music, not spontaneous improvisations or spoken-word performances. In my view, every piece of music is a meticulously crafted, planned product, designed to communicate non-verbal meanings and subliminal impacts through the careful use of time. Since time is the essential component of music, every piece must be composed to an exact duration that fits the piece perfectly.

The Role of the Composer

A composer is the master strategist, tasked with knowing precisely when, how, and where to start and end a piece of music. The entire composition, including the content in between, must fit seamlessly with what precedes and follows. When everything is in sync, strong expectations are aroused in the very texture of the composition. These expectations must be successfully resolved, making great music far more than just a mere resolution. Great compositions go beyond what the listener can imagine, generating and reinforcing a sense of inevitability and coherence.

The listener is pulled into the music and becomes a part of it, almost a prisoner of the piece. The release from these chains comes only when the piece ends. This compelling reason underscores the need for a precise ending, one that is neither premature nor delayed. In essence, the composer must be both a master psychologist and a master strategist.

Adapting to Modern Listener Preferences

While this meticulous approach to composition is crucial, it is equally important for new composers to recognize the subtle shifts in modern attention spans. Over the past 80 years, our ability to focus for extended periods has been on a steady decline. As consumers, we are now geared towards quick meals and quick changes of subject. We have become more flighty in aspects of life, and this flightiness must be considered when creating art.

The delicate balance between spectacle and substance is precarious at best. New composers would do well to keep this balance in mind. While creative freedom is essential, understanding the concise nature of modern attention can help in crafting pieces that engage listeners.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the length of a musical composition is a critical element of its structure and impact. Compositions must be carefully planned and crafted to fit a specific duration that resonates with the listener. For new composers, it is vital to strike a balance between adhering to the timeless principles of composition and understanding the modern audience's preferences. By doing so, they can create works that are both structurally sound and engaging to contemporary listeners.