The Best Way to Tune Your Electric Guitar: Amp On or Off?

When it comes to tuning an electric guitar, the age-old question often arises: should you tune with the amp on or off? Let's dive into the pros and cons of each method and provide some tips to help you determine the best approach for your needs.

Why Tune with the Amp Off?

Tuning with the amp off offers several benefits that can make the process more efficient and accurate.

Noise Reduction: Without the sound of the amp in the mix, you can hear the guitar strings more clearly, making it easier to discern whether the note is in tune. Precision: Clip-on tuners and pedal tuners can pick up the vibrations of the strings more accurately in the absence of background noise, leading to a more precise tuning. Interference: Amplifiers can produce noise or feedback that might introduce inaccuracies when tuning, especially with certain types of pickups or tuners.

For a more in-depth look at this process, consider the following tips:

Use a clip-on tuner or a pedal tuner, as they are less likely to be affected by the sound from the amp. Ensure the amp is turned off or use a tuner with an input that can be used with or without an amp. Use a mobile tuner app with a good microphone or rely on a guitar with onboard pickups for more accurate tuning.

When to Tune with the Amp On?

While it's generally recommended to tune with the amp off, there are scenarios where tuning with the amp on might be more convenient or suitable.

Pedal Tuners: If you are using a pedal tuner, it's perfectly fine to tune with the amp on, as these devices can compensate for the added noise. Situational Needs: In live performances or when you need a louder tuning sound, tuning with the amp on can be more practical. Convenience: If you are tuning by ear and prefer a louder reference, you can turn the amp to a decent volume.

For situations where an amp is necessary, such as live tuning or for a louder tuning sound, you can consider the following:

Ensure the amp is not set to an extremely high volume to avoid unwanted noise. Place the amp in a way that it does not interfere with your session. Use a mute pedal, such as those from Saturnworks, Smokin' Amp Co., or Loopi Pedals, to eliminate the signal during the tuning process.

Conclusion

The method of tuning your electric guitar with the amp on or off ultimately depends on your personal preference and the specific situation you are dealing with. Whether you prefer a quiet, precise tuning environment without the amp or a louder, more lively setting, there are tools and techniques available to assist you. From clip-on tuners to app-based tuners, to modern tuner pedals, the options are varied, and the choice should be based on what works best for you and your playing style.