The Debate on Thick Guitar Picks: Hardness vs. Thickness
The choice of guitar picks is a highly personal one, with many factors influencing a guitarist's preference. This includes the hardness and thickness of the pick, among other factors such as material and shape. In this article, we explore the nuances of whether thicker guitar picks are better, delving into the experiences of both beginners and more seasoned players.
The Role of Thickness in Playability
Many guitarists find that hardness is more important than thickness when it comes to pick selection. A completely rigid pick allows for better control and expression, which can be crucial for certain styles of guitar playing.
However, others argue the opposite. They maintain that the pick should allow them to play how they want, even if that means using no pick at all. For such players, a pick that is too thick or too thin can hinder their performance.
Popular Picks for Various Styles
There is no one-size-fits-all answer to what is the best guitar pick, as it depends on the individual's preferences and the style of music they play. However, some picks are popular among guitarists for their balance of stiffness and availability.
For example, the Jazz 3 XL is a go-to choice for many guitarists. It offers the right combination of stiffness and thickness, and is readily available in most music stores. Another popular choice is the Herco 60's Extra Thin Nylon, which is ideal for acoustic strumming, providing a loud, bright, and clear tone.
Customizing Picks for Different Techniques
Some pick manufacturers offer options that can be customized to suit specific playing techniques. For instance, guitarists can use kitchen shears to cut Fender regular picks to the desired size for a more flexible and reactive pick. Similarly, thicker picks can be used for playing solo lines or acoustic flatpicking, providing better control for picking single notes.
There are various types of picks available, ranging from the common Dunlop jazz 3 in nylon to more plucky pumpkin seed-shaped picks, which offer a brighter top end. Smaller, thinner picks may be more suitable for beginners who are still developing their technique, as they are more forgiving. However, for experienced players with well-developed picking chops, thicker picks can reduce movement during play and make it easier to play single-note lines.
Personal Preference: The Final Verdict
Ultimately, the choice of pick thickness comes down to personal preference. What is “better” for one player may not be suitable for another. It is essential to try different picks and find the one that works best for your style of play. As a guitarist, you should follow your preference and not be swayed by external opinions.
In conclusion, whether thicker guitar picks are better depends on individual preferences and playing styles. What matters most is that the pick allows you to play the way you want, enhancing your tone and technique without hindering your performance. Whether you prefer a thick pick for its control or a thinner pick for its flexibility, the key is to find the balance that suits you best.