The Greatest Pianists in Rock and Roll

The debate over who is the greatest pianist in the history of rock and roll can be a matter of personal opinion. While some may argue that Elton John takes the crown, a closer look reveals that the title may belong to a different, lesser-known player.

Is Elton John Really the Greatest?

Elton John, while undoubtedly one of the most iconic pianists in modern music, is not, in the strictest sense, considered the greatest pianist in rock and roll. This title is often attributed to figures from earlier, more foundational periods of rock music, such as the great New Orleans piano masters.

New Orleans Piano Kings

Many of the greatest rock and roll pianists hail from New Orleans, a city renowned for its unique musical heritage. Among these luminaries are:

Professor Longhair: Known for his rollicking piano style, he brought a raw, percussive sound to the piano that has influenced generations. Dr. John: Formerly known as Mac Rebennack, this musician's genre-defying style blends blues, rock, and jazz, showcasing his technical prowess. Fats Domino: A pioneer of rock and roll, his music laid the foundation for much of the genre that followed. Allen Toussaint: His songwriting and arranging skills have left an indelible mark on the genre, and his piano playing is considered some of the finest in rock and roll. Little Richard: Though not a pianist in the traditional sense, his piano playing was one of the most influential in modern music, influencing figures like Elton John. Art Neville: A key member of the Neville Brothers, his piano playing is both virtuosic and funky. Huey “Piano” Smith: Known for his incredible left-hand bass playing, his technique is unmatched in the genre. James Booker: Often cited as the finest piano player in rock and roll, his ability to blend jazz, blues, and rock in a solo setting is unparalleled.

James Booker: The Best Technique

Among these masters, James Booker is often regarded as having the best technique. His ability to blend various genres seamlessly and his unique tone make him a standout player. Professor Longhair comes in a very close second, known for his raw, energetic style that helped define the sound of New Orleans music.

Other Influential Pianists

Johnny Johnson also deserves mention. Though not as well-known as some of the aforementioned players, his work with Chuck Berry, particularly on the song "Johnny B. Goode," showcases incredible rhythmic and technical skills. His ability to play between the beats helped give the music its distinctive edge.

Elton John and His Style

Elton John's style was heavily influenced by many of these New Orleans pianists. His own playing, while showy and technically proficient, does not match the rawness and emotional depth that defined the work of his predecessors. He acknowledges this himself, noting that his fingers are shorter and stubbier, but makes up for it with strength and a keen sense of rhythm.

Keith Emerson: The Keyboard Magazine’s Take

According to Keyboard magazine, the title of the best rock pianist may belong to Keith Emerson. While opinions on this may vary, the comparison between Emerson and Booker or Longhair highlights the subjective nature of such a title.

In conclusion, while Elton John may be a fantastic pianist in his own right, the best pianists in the history of rock and roll are more likely to be found among the pioneers of New Orleans jazz. These musicians, with their unique styles and technical prowess, are the true titans of rock piano.