The Illustrious Fanbases: Exploring the Worst Among Music Lovers
When it comes to fanbases, some are more zealous, some more eccentrical, and some outright annoying. Over the years, I've had to deal with multiple fanbases that skewer our beloved artists to a level almost divine. But today, we'll take a closer look at one fanbase that arguably takes the cake—those who view their idols as otherworldly muses speaking exclusively to them.
The Case of Bj?rk's Dedicated Fans
Bj?rk is a prime example of how a fanbase can transform a musical artist into a mystic, creating a spiritual and exclusive experience for listeners. In 2023, when an analysis of Bj?rk's music was posted on the scientific website ResearchGate, it revealed that her compositions are highly subjective and deeply rooted in her personal experiences. This raises the question: is there any real connection for the listener, or is the music solely for her?
Understanding the Analysis
The study on Bj?rk's music suggested that popular songs serve as expressions of emotional experiences rooted in either the performer's, the listener's, or a virtual third person. It argued that organised sound can represent or embody a pre-existent affective experience. More importantly, however, the study highlighted that music contributes uniquely to the idea of what emotion is and how it is perceived. Two case studies were presented: the track "Unison" from Vespertine (2001) and the music video "Jóga" from Volumen (1999).
This analysis implies that Bj?rk's music, while evocative and layered, is deeply personal and may not connect meaningfully with all listeners. It's exclusive to her, not the listener. Whether or not one relates to the music, it's primarily about her experiences and emotions.
The Personal Esoterica
Bj?rk's music often resonates with fans who see her as an ethereal, otherworldly figure. They believe her music is a transcendent spiritual experience, almost like a religious ritual. However, this belief can be a double-edged sword. When fans are deeply invested and treat the artist's music with almost religious fervor, it can lead to a polarizing environment. Those who don't share this belief are often dismissed as not part of the enlightened group.
Impacting Critics and Public Perception
Music critics like Rolling Stone can also play a role in shaping public perception. In their seminal list of "The 100 Worst Albums of the 90s," Nirvana found its place, labeled by the magazine as a pivotal act with a devoted fanbase that could be annoyingly devoted. This underscores how even critics can be influenced by fan enthusiasm. Yet, Rolling Stone itself may have once admired Nirvana, making the list even more divisive.
Diving into Narcissism
Narcissism, an underlying trait in some fanbases, plays a critical role here. Narcissists often believe they are superior and unique, and their art is an exclusive possession. This belief can lead to fans dismissing those who don't appreciate the artist, accusing them of not being smart enough or mature enough. It fosters an elitist mindset where only the initiated can truly understand the artist's work.
Narcissism in Fanbehaviour: Just as a narcissist feels they need a small select group to understand them, their admiration (or lack thereof) for an artist is exclusive. If someone doesn't appreciate the art, they are labelled as not being at the right intellectual or even spiritual level. Real Versus Imagined Connection: The sense of a personal, mystical connection can sometimes be a mirage. Fans may be ascribing meaning to random elements, much like how unintelligent people can find significance in random words or sound.Ultimately, while an artist like Bj?rk can indeed create a profound and layered experience, it's crucial to maintain a balance. Music, at its core, should be accessible and relatable for a wide audience. Polarizing fanbases can sometimes overshadow the true artistry and universal appeal of an artist.
Conclusion: Whether it's Nirvana, Bj?rk, or any other artist, the strength and divisiveness of fanbases can sometimes create a hostile environment. It's important to recognize that while fan enthusiasm can greatly contribute to an artist's legacy, it's equally important to encourage a diverse and inclusive appreciation of the music.