What else could Lyanna have asked Ned Stark to promise if Jon Snow is not truly her son?

In the rich and complex narrative of Game of Thrones, a pivotal question remains: what if Jon Snow is not actually the son of Lyanna Stark and Rhaegar Targaryen as widely believed? Considering the depth of Lyanna's character, it's possible that she could have asked Ned Stark to promise something entirely different. Here are several alternative promises that Lyanna might have made to ensure her child's future and the delicate balance of power in Westeros.

Protection of a Different Child

One of the most compelling possibilities is that Lyanna might have asked Ned to protect a different child, possibly one with a different father or even another child she had with Rhaegar. This would have been a solution to ensure that the child's identity remained hidden from political intrigue and kept safe from potential threats. The secrecy would have been paramount, ensuring that the true parentage of the child remained a mystery, thus preventing any unnecessary conflicts or betrayals.

Keeping Her Memory Alive

Another profound promise Lyanna might have made is to ensure that her legacy and memory were honored within the Stark family. This could involve ensuring that her story was told and her values remembered. Additionally, she might have requested that a child within the Stark family be named after her, symbolizing her continued presence within the Stark lineage and ensuring that her legacy lived on. Such a promise would add a layer of emotional depth to her character and assist in the narrative's exploration of the themes of memory and legacy.

A Promise of Loyalty

Lyanna could have also asked Ned to remain loyal to the Targaryens, as a way to maintain the peace between the North and the South. This loyalty could have involved supporting Rhaegar's claim or protecting Targaryen loyalists. While this might seem contradictory to her known actions, it would have added complexity to her character, revealing deep-seated beliefs and motivations that could span beyond her mere desire to have her child protected. This promise would have a significant impact on the broader narrative, influencing political dynamics and alliances.

Secrecy About Her Relationship with Rhaegar

If Lyanna's relationship with Rhaegar was more complex than being merely the mother of Jon, she might have asked Ned to keep their bond a secret. This request could be made to protect Rhaegar's reputation or shield herself from the stigma of being a Targaryen consort. Such a promise would have far-reaching implications, shaping perceptions and influencing the political landscape in Westeros. It would add a layer of intrigue to the narrative, as her true relationship with Rhaegar remains a mystery.

Care for a Specific Person

Lyanna might have requested that Ned care for a specific person important to her, such as a friend or a member of her family. This would ensure that individual's safety and well-being, adding a personal touch to her request and highlighting the depth of her relationships. Ensuring the care of someone important would add emotional depth to the story and create additional narrative layers.

A Vow of Non-Aggression

She could have asked Ned to promise that the Starks would not retaliate against the Targaryens, especially if there were tensions brewing between their families. This would have the effect of maintaining a fragile peace and preventing the escalation of conflicts. Such a vow of non-aggression would have significant implications for the broader narrative, shaping alliances and ensuring a more peaceful coexistence in Westeros.

A Promise to Raise Jon Differently

If Jon were not her son, Lyanna might have asked Ned to raise Jon in a specific way, teaching him values that reflect her own beliefs or keeping him away from certain dangers. This would have a profound impact on Jon's character and development, revealing Lyanna's true intentions and beliefs. Supporting Jon's personal growth and well-being in this way would ensure that his values and actions align with her vision for his future.

A Vow of Peace

Finally, Lyanna may have asked Ned to work towards peace between the North and the Targaryens. This vow of peace would have been a way to bridge the gap between the two regions and ensure a more stable and harmonious Westeros. It would add a layer of hope and optimism to the narrative, as the complexities of the story would be explored through the lens of an ongoing conflict that is potentially resolvable through mutual cooperation and understanding.

Each of these alternative promises would add layers to the narrative and could significantly impact the relationships and events in the series. By considering these possibilities, we can delve deeper into the complex motivations and character arcs of Lyanna Stark and Ned Stark, enriching our understanding of the intricate world of A Song of Ice and Fire.