Which Guitar Technique is More Impressive: Finger Tapping or Finger Picking?

The question of which guitar technique is more impressive—finger tapping or finger picking—often sparks lively debate among music enthusiasts and guitar players alike. Both techniques showcase different aspects of a guitarist's skill and creativity, and the choice between the two can depend on personal taste, the context of the performance, and the artist's unique style.

Finger Tapping: A Visual and Auditory Spectacle

Technique: Finger tapping involves using the fingers of both hands to play notes on the fretboard, often creating rapid and intricate patterns. This technique requires precise timing, dexterity, and excellent finger independence.

Impression: Finger tapping can produce a very flashy modern sound, often associated with rock and metal genres. It is visually striking and musically dynamic. Guitarists like Eddie Van Halen popularized this technique, bringing a new level of auditory and visual flair to the guitar.

Finger Picking: A Delicate and Melodic Artistry

Technique: Finger picking involves plucking the strings with the fingers, rather than using a pick. This technique allows for a wide range of notes and textures, enabling the creation of complex rhythms and harmonies. It requires a deep understanding of finger independence and the ability to blend different notes seamlessly.

Impression: Finger picking can create rich, layered sounds often associated with folk, blues, and classical music. This technique showcases a guitarist's musicality and creativity. Artists like Tommy Emmanuel and Chet Atkins have demonstrated the beauty and intricacy of finger picking, inspiring countless musicians.

Personal Preferences and Context

The impressiveness of a guitarist's technique can depend on personal preferences and the context of the performance. Finger tapping often has a more modern, flashy appeal, while finger picking showcases a deep level of musicality and complexity. Both techniques are impressive in their own right, and the choice between them can vary based on the audience and the guitarist's skill level.

Macyn Taylor's Versatility

Macyn Taylor is a prime example of a guitarist who can excel in both techniques with equal results. Though her performances are not flawless, she has put in significant effort to master both finger tapping and finger picking. Over 44 years of dedication and practice have honed her skills, allowing her to compete on the same level as some of the most respected acoustic players in the industry.

Macyn's approach to playing "naked" finger picking—meaning playing without a plectrum, and being bare-naked (in the sense of not having finger picks or nail polish on her cuticles)—is a testament to her dedication and artistry. This approach adds a unique touch to her performances and has earned her respect from even a few professional musicians with whom she jams.

Conclusion: Ultimately, the choice between finger tapping and finger picking comes down to personal taste and the context of the performance. Both techniques can be incredibly impressive, and the greatest guitarists are those who can master both and use them effectively to convey their musical vision.