Why Cover Songs Are Rare in Rap/Hip-Hop: Explaining the Genre Expectations

In the realm of music, genres often have unique expectations that shape how they evolve and are consumed. Cover songs, which are re-recordings of existing songs by other artists, are less common in the rap and hip-hop genres. This article will explore why cover songs are so rare in these genres, delving into the reasons behind this phenomenon.

Rap and Hip-Hop in a Nutshell

Cover songs are indeed found in hip-hop and rap music, albeit to a lesser extent. Just like other genres, there are notable examples. For instance, Gangstarr, a well-known rap group, covered the rock song 'It's Alright' by Manson, and Red Rock Infidel, a rock band, covered The Reply by Post Malone. However, these instances are rare and often involve notable collaborations, such as the involvement of guest rappers featured in Gangstarr's cover.

Individuality and Originality in Rap and Hip-Hop

The expectations for cover songs in the rap and hip-hop genres diverge significantly from those in other music genres. For example, a classical musician is expected to perform a piece accurately, whereas a jazz artist may opt for improvisation. In the case of rap and hip-hop, lyrics are often considered sacred: they are personal, reflective of the artist’s experience and viewpoint. Genuine hip-hop tracks are expected to showcase the rapper’s own talents, with lyrics serving as a testament to their lyrical prowess. A track that is not noteworthy in terms of chorus or melody often relies heavily on the lyrics to convey its message.

The Prevalence of Originality and Ego in Rap

Many rappers are driven by a strong sense of identity and individuality. Covering another artist's work could be seen as a form of imitation, which may be perceived as a betrayal of one's own artistry. In the realm of hip-hop, Run DMC's cover of 'Walk This Way' by Aerosmith stands out as an exceptional example. This cover played a significant role in bringing hip-hop into the mainstream, but it was still a one-off. Most rappers are reluctant to cover songs outside of hip-hop, and even when they do, the results are often met with mixed reactions.

The Role of Cred and Image in Rap and Hip-Hop

In the world of rap and hip-hop, concept like cred and image hold a lot of weight. For many rappers, a cover could be perceived as a sign of lip service or a lack of confidence in their own work. It’s common for a rap artist to feel that covering another artist’s work is a disingenuous move. Furthermore, this genre is often plagued by petty disputes, which can make covering another artist’s work even more challenging. The image of a rapper or hip-hop artist is typically tied to their originality and ability to express their unique experiences and perspectives.

Limited Appeal of Hip-Hop Covers

While there are certainly notable exceptions, hip-hop covers tend to have a more limited appeal. They often cater to a niche audience that appreciates the genre for its complexity and artistry. For example, Richard Cheese and Lounge Against the Machine, known for their eclectic style and unconventional covers, have a band of true connoisseurs who appreciate their reimagining of hip-hop classics. Their cover of "Gin and Juice" by Snoop Dogg is a prime example, featuring a different vocal style and a distinct arrangement that could change one’s opinion of the original track. Similarly, their cover of Cardi B’s ‘WAP’ includes a lovely piano part and a sensitive vocal, demonstrating how covers can transform and appreciate the original work.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the rarity of cover songs in rap and hip-hop is due to the strong emphasis on individuality, originality, and a clear sense of identity within these genres. The expectations and cultural norms of the genre make it difficult for artists to cover songs without being criticized or seen as lacking in authenticity. However, there are exceptions that showcase the artistry and creativity that can arise from reimagining and reinterpreting existing works. The genre’s essence relies on the raw, personal, and unique expressions of artists, making cover songs a less common phenomenon in the world of rap and hip-hop.