Why Doesn't Depeche Mode Play Songs from Their Album A Broken Frame?
Depeche Mode's decision to rarely play songs from their 1982 album A Broken Frame during live performances can be attributed to several factors.
Changing Musical Direction
After the release of A Broken Frame, the band evolved their sound significantly, experimenting with different styles and themes in subsequent albums. This shift may have led them to prioritize songs that align more closely with their later work. The musical landscape they moved into is quite different from the band's earlier sound, which may explain why some fans feel a disconnect with the album.
Song Popularity
Many of the tracks on A Broken Frame did not achieve the same level of commercial success or fan recognition as songs from their later albums. The band often focuses on their most popular hits when touring to connect with their audience and ensure a memorable experience for concertgoers. Given the different eras and styles, it's understandable why some of the songs from A Broken Frame are less likely to be featured on their setlists.
Band Dynamics
The album was released shortly after the departure of Vince Clarke, a founding member of the band. This change in lineup may have impacted the band's connection to the material. The remaining members—Martin Gore and Dave Gahan—have focused on tracks that resonate more with their current identity as a band. The emotional and musical links they have to the newer material might influence their setlists more than songs from A Broken Frame.
Setlist Variety
Depeche Mode has a vast catalog of music, and they tend to mix their setlists to keep performances fresh. Mixing in songs from various eras helps to maintain audience engagement and prevent monotony. This often results in the exclusion of songs from earlier albums, especially those that are less well-known. Songs from A Broken Frame, while appreciated by some fans, might not fit as seamlessly into this mix.
Fan Expectations
While some fans appreciate the deeper cuts, most concertgoers expect to hear the band's biggest hits. The selection of songs for live performances is often influenced by what the audience is likely to enjoy. The big hits, such as "People Are People" and others, provide a guaranteed connection with the audience, ensuring a positive and memorable experience for the crowd.
It's important to note that while A Broken Frame has its fans and contains notable tracks, the combination of these factors contributes to its limited representation in live shows. The band is known for their ability to evolve and adapt, and focusing on newer material allows them to stay connected with their modern fans.
Comparatively, some other bands might revisit older albums more frequently, like U2, whose second most played song is "I Will Follow" from their first album Boy from 1980. Every band has its unique approach to setlists, catering to the tastes of their audience while also reflecting the band's ongoing evolution.
Depeche Mode, being a band that is not nostalgic or inclined to rehash the past, can be seen as a testament to their commitment to their current sound and the music they feel most aligned with in the present moment.