Worst Cover Versions That Ruin Iconic Songs

Music covers have been a staple of the music industry for decades, allowing musicians to reinterpret and reinvigorate existing songs. However, not all cover versions are met with the same enthusiasm, especially from fans who hold the original versions in high regard. In this article, we explore some of the worst cover versions that deviate so far from the original that they are easily recognized as severe misinterpretations.

The Bryan Ferry Approach: A Hard Rain’s A-Gonna Fall

Three years of my life were defined by Bryan Ferry, his albums, and his live performances. However, Ferry's cover of Bob Dylan's “A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall” is a prime example of a cover that went horribly wrong. Despite Ferry's acclaimed status as a master interpreter of music by other artists, this particular rendition stands out as subpar.

My issue with Ferry's version is not merely a case of denaturing the song. Even the original version of “A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall” doesn't hold a candle to Ferry’s take. The singer performs in a way that seems uncontrollably excited, as if infected with rabies. He croons with overenthusiasm, as if he were swallowing the microphone whole and clawing his way out of the recording studio. Ferry's first two solo albums, in particular, are a series of disappointments.

The Distasteful Elton John Dance Remixes

Elton John's iconic songs have been subjected to numerous dance remixes, but not all of them have been met with approval. I can't help but cringe every time I hear his dance remixes. While some remixes might cater to the tastes of electronic dance music fans, they often strip away the essence of the originals. The remixes take away the nuances and depth that made Elton John's songs memorable, reducing them to mere beats and rhythms.

The Dixie Chicks and Smashing Pumpkins: Landslide

Sarah McLachlan's version of Fleetwood Mac's "Landslide" is often hailed as the definitive cover, but some artists have tackled it in ways that irk longtime fans. The Dixie Chicks and Smashing Pumpkins both made passable but ultimately unsatisfactory interpretations. The original is a perfect version, with every note contributing to its magic. The cover versions, however, lack the emotional depth and authenticity of the original.

It’s Not About Innovation, It’s About Respect

When it comes to cover versions, it's not just about innovating or adding a new twist to a song. The essence of the original must be respected and honored. Many cover versions that fail to do so reveal a lack of true appreciation for the original artists' intentions and the classics they have birthed. Such cover versions can be a missed opportunity to pay homage to those who created something truly special.

Conclusion

While music covers have their place in the world of music, it's crucial to recognize that they should not overshadow the original versions. When a cover version loses sight of the original's spirit and essence, it can come off as disrespectful and even offensive to fans of the original artists. Bryan Ferry's take on “A Hard Rain's A-Gonna Fall,” Elton John’s dance remixes, and the Dixie Chicks and Smashing Pumpkins' version of "Landslide" are clear examples of when this went wrong. These cover versions remind us why we hold certain original versions in such high regard and why it's important to respect and preserve the art of the original creators.