Reevaluating Blackpink: The Disconnect Between Performances and Fan Loyalty
In recent times, a significant number of Blinks (Blackpink fans) have started to unstanning the famous K-pop group. While this trend might initially seem surprising, it boils down to a broader issue of disconnect between the group's performance quality and the fanbase's expectations. This article delves into the reasons behind this shift and whether the performances align with the fans' experiences and values.
Reasons Behind the Unstan
One of the primary reasons for Blinks unstanning Blackpink is the perceived lack of passion and dedication during live performances. Fans report that the group often shows a lack of enthusiasm when performing for their fans, which differs starkly from their lively and energetic displays in clubs and parties. For fans who travel long distances and save for years to experience a full concert performance, obtaining just a glimpse of an unenthusiastic group performing the bare minimum is undoubtedly disappointing. This ungrateful and aloof attitude further fuels the unstan phenomenon among fans.
Doubts About the Group’s Commitment
The group's capability of performing on stage, or a lack thereof, is a recurring topic of discussion. It's been noted that unlike some other members in the entertainment industry, Blackpink doesn't seem to pour their heart and soul into their live performances. Videos and pictures have surfaced of the group dancing gracefully at clubs and parties, whereas during events where their fans are paying to witness their performances, they seem to struggle. This inconsistency between their personal and professional lives is a significant concern for many fans. The expectation is that artists should pay genuine tribute to their fans, especially who spend so much to see them perform live. This disparity extends to the group's songwriting efforts, as it appears they primarily perform pre-written content rather than original compositions. It's important to recognize that the people behind the music are critical to the entire fan experience.
Limitations of Authenticity and Appreciation
Another issue at the heart of this disconnect is the regard for authenticity and the group's true appreciation of their fanbase. Blinks often feel unacknowledged, with some performances so mediocre that fans feel inclined to put together tutorials and videos that showcase better attempts. While having 2 good performances out of 20 might seem like a mixed record, it can often be indicative of a consistent lack of effort. Blinks, who dedicate their time and money to support the group, deserve the best from them, and seeing bare minimum effort is not what they envisioned when first jumping on the fan train.
Analysis of Individual Members
The individual members of Blackpink are often praised and criticized for their performances, and a closer look at each member reveals a mixed picture.
Lisa: Standing out as the only genuine performer, Lisa has been reaffirmed as the face of the group. Her energy and charisma shine through in her dance movements. Although minor inconsistencies exist, her efforts and passion are clear, making her a favorite among many fans.
Rose: Consistently seen putting her best foot forward, Rose tends to lack the sparkle needed for performances. Her robotic-looking dance routines and expression seem to fizzle out on stage. However, her dedication to making the best of every performance is commendable, even if it means looking less than her best for it.
Jisoo: At a below-average performance level, Jisoo has faced criticism for her dance routines. The lack of synchronization and overall energy often leave her in the shadows of her more dynamic teammates. Fans hope to see a more energized and improved performance from her.
Jennie: Jennie's performances can be both captivating and confusing. Sometimes appearing genuine, at other times, her sincerity wavers. Club appearances and energetic club dancing instincts make it challenging to determine if she is faking illness for performances where her fans are paying to see her. Truthfully, her performances need an overhaul and an injection of genuine enthusiasm to cater to her fanbase.
Synchronization and Choreography: This critical issue of synchronization has been a long-standing complaint. Despite choreographies being considered simple in the K-pop industry, the lack of coordination still makes a significant difference in the overall appeal of the performance. It is not only disappointing but also a reflection of the group's overall dedication during events where fans are their priority.
The unstan movement among Blinks is a complex issue that involves multiple dimensions, including the group’s performance quality, their personal lives, and overall dedication. While fans can continue to support the group, it's important for Blackpink to understand and address the underlying concerns raised by their loyal fanbase to maintain the trust and enthusiasm that fans have shown in the past.