U2: The Great Live Band Debate

Do people generally think that U2 is a great live band? While opinions can certainly vary, my personal experience over six performances with U2 provides some insight. In this article, I will delve into my thoughts and observations on U2's live performances and evaluate whether they truly live up to the expectations of being a legendary live act.

The Verdict: A Balanced Perspective

Let me start by stating that the verb tense is significant here. My initial impression was that U2 was a great live band, a sentiment I have maintained to this day. However, their live performances have gone through various phases, each with its unique characteristics.

Early Twenties and Optimal Performances

Up until around the work with Amnesty International, U2's live concerts were enjoyable. The performances marked by the albums 'Achtung Baby' and 'Zooropa' saw a shift in their live style, which to me, made the live material less appealing. My top ten best performances include two shows which, although still excellent, don't quite make the top five.

Lineups and Sound Issues

Two of the performances in my bottom ten list were due to sound issues typical in stadium settings. The other two shows were considered very good, suggesting that the band's prowess in front of a live audience has been consistent over time.

Personal Experience and Rarities

My personal experience with U2 dates back to the year 2000 during the 'All That You Can't Leave Behind' tour. While it was a good show, my memory of it is not overwhelmingly vivid. This experience, along with their strong live recordings such as 'Under a Blood Red Sky' and 'Wide Awake in America,' supports my belief in their enduring live presence from the early days of their career.

Evaluation and Underrated Status

Despite the claims that U2 is underrated in the discussion about great live bands, I feel that their live performances are often overlooked. The members of U2, especially Bono and The Edge, have a palpable chemistry and a distinct presence that many other bands lack. While the band has downplayed their musical skills in interviews, their musical acumen can be heard loud and clear, underscoring their talented musicianship.

Conclusion: An Overlooked Gem

While I believe that U2 is indeed a great live band, my personal appreciation is rooted in a balanced perspective. The band's impact and energy have consistently been present, even if their style has evolved over the years. Whether they are underrated in the discussion about legendary live acts can be subjective, but their live performances remain a testament to their enduring talent and dedication.

As I reflect on my experiences and the countless others who have been impressed by U2's live shows, it's clear that the band continues to provide an unforgettable live experience. So, is U2 a great live band? Yes, they certainly are, and they continue to deserve their place among the great live acts.